|
GRASS-BASED FUEL INFORMATION:
If you are
familiar with grass fuel or pelleting and briquetting you have probably heard
that grass pellets do not burn as well as wood pellets because of
any one of a number of common reasons. The two most common
explanations are that they have a very high ash content and that
they are corrosive to the combustion equipment. It is also
common to hear that they cause pollution and that they have less
energy content per pound than wood pellets. All of these
statements are misleading and the purpose of this page is to shed
light on the subject of grass pellets.
ASH CONTENT
& COMPOSITION:
Much research has been done on the use of grass pellets and how they
compare to wood pellets by various groups. BHS Energy has done
a significant amount of research and the materials reviewed
indicate that grass pellets have only about 3-4% ash as compared to
the 0.5-3% ash allowed of premium wood pellets. The actual issue is not
so much the
quantity of ash but the composition of the ash. Switchgrass,
when harvested, contains more calcium and phosphorus than wood and
therefore the ash that is left over after combustion has a lower melting point. Because of this it can
form "clinkers" during combustion in stoves that are not designed to
deal with such ash. This is the same issue encountered when burning corn
and therefore at this time it is believed that many corn stoves should
work well for burning grass pellets as they are designed with more
aggressive ash removal systems. Many newer pellet stoves are also
designed to handle multiple fuel types, and more and more manufacturers of
combustion equipment are beginning to advertise that their stoves &
boilers can handle grass pellets. Also note that 3-4% ash is still
insignificant as compared to the ~30% ash contained in coal. In
most cases, with modern combustion equipment, ash should only need
to be emptied a few times per week at most.
In addition to
"clinkers", another issue encountered due to grass pellet composition is
the corrosion of the combustion equipment. This may be
partially true and more research needs to be done on the subject.
However, this problem is not unique to grass pellets as combusting
all biomass including wood causes corrosion in combustion equipment
to one degree or another. Because of this many stoves and boilers are
already built with corrosion resistant features such as stainless steel
burn pots and smoke pipes. Also
there is experimentation with adding a base chemical such as lime
to grass prior to pelleting to help prevent corrosion.
BURN
EFFICIENCY AND POLLUTION:
Sometimes we will hear that grass pellets
pollute the environment more than other sources of bio-heating and
this is untrue. The fact is that the pollution created by the
combustion of any biomass depends entirely on the efficiency of the
combustion equipment. In most cases grass pellets, just like
wood pellets, burn very efficiently with the only significant
pollutant released being carbon dioxide. When combusting fossil
fuels, the carbon is removed from the ground and put into the
atmosphere during combustion. With biomass, the carbon dioxide put into the
atmosphere during combustion is reabsorbed by the
plants as they grow ultimately making the entire cycle from growth
to combustion carbon neutral. This
is possible because the native grasses involved have an extensive root
system and they sequester carbon in the soil permanently as they
grow which offsets pollution created during the harvesting and
densificaiton of the raw biomass materials. Another large benefit of this carbon
sequestration is that it improves soil quality dramatically over
time. There is research available and still
being done on the specifics but BHS Energy is confident that the
combustion of easily renewable biomass, such as switchgrass and
other native prairie grasses, is among the most
environmentally friendly and benign sources of energy currently
available.
ENERGY (BTU)
CONTENT:
Another very commonly asked question is "How much energy per ton is
contained in grass pellets compared to wood pellets?" The
answer is that all biomass contains essentially the same energy
content minus the particular ash content. Therefore if you are comparing
one ton of wood pellets with 2% ash and one ton of grass pellets with 3%
ash, the difference in energy is about 1%. So if the 2% ash wood
pellets contain 16,000,000 BTU's (which is true, approximately), then the 3% ash
grass pellets contain
15,840,000 BTU's. This is an insignificant difference. In other words,
the short answer is that grass pellets and wood pellets contain
approximately the
same amount of energy per any given weight.
|